Afghanistan After America: A Conversation With Laurel Miller and Graeme Smith

20年战争一场空?深度复盘美军撤离真相!

The Foreign Affairs Interview

2026-08-27

1 小时 15 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

Five years ago this month, the United States ended its war in Afghanistan. Washington’s exit was chaotic; as Taliban forces swept through the country and the U.S.-backed government collapsed, officials scrambled to evacuate tens of thousands of Afghans who might fall victim to repression and retribution. In the years since, Afghanistan has practically vanished from American foreign policy discussion. But the situation in the country remains dire, and the collective forgetting of the United States’ longest war carries costs of its own. Laurel Miller and Graeme Smith have each spent many years working on and within Afghanistan. Miller, now president of the Asia Foundation, was a longtime U.S. diplomat who became a top official focused on Afghanistan from 2013 to 2017. Smith worked as a political affairs officer for the United Nations in Afghanistan from 2015 to 2018 before serving as an Afghanistan analyst for the International Crisis Group. Dan Kurtz-Phelan spoke to Miller and Smith on Tuesday, August 25, about the lessons and legacy of the American war in Afghanistan, how the country has changed under Taliban rule, and the questions that U.S. policymakers should grapple with moving forward. You can find sources, transcripts, and more episodes of The Foreign Affairs Interview at https://www.foreignaffairs.com/podcasts/foreign-affairs-interview.
更多

单集文稿 ...

  • I'm Dan Kurtz-Phelan and this is the Foreign Affairs interview.

  • In terms of the sort of broader case for why we had to remain

  • militarily engaged in Afghanistan year after year after year,

  • the core thesis was we have to fight them over there

  • so that we don't fight them over here in the West.

  • Now those exact words were spoken in Western parliaments

  • and now five years on, you know I think empirically knock on wood, it's just not the case, right?

  • If you look at the fact that for 20 years

  • Afghanistan was such a high priority to the United States

  • that the US expended blood and an enormous amount of treasure

  • to be there to prop up the Afghan government,

  • to build up the Afghan security forces,

  • to prosecute a counterterrorism campaign

  • and then all at once the US can leave the country,

  • have very little engagement with Afghanistan,

  • have it completely drop off the policy map and nothing happens,

  • has to make you question the strategic choices

  • and judgments during that long period of time.

  • Five years ago this month, America ended its war in Afghanistan.

  • The exit was chaotic, Taliban forces swept through the country