Welcome to Overthink.
The podcast where your two favorite philosophers steal the show by putting ideas in dialogue with everyday life.
I'm Ellie Anderson.
And I'm David Peña Guzman.
And as always, for an ad-free extended version of this episode,
community discussion, and more, subscribe to Overthink on Substack.
We all learn as kids that stealing is wrong.
Maybe you grew up hearing, as I did, thou shall not steal as one of the Ten Commandments, for instance.
But one of the weird things is that we also tend to have a deeply ingrained
moral intuition that stealing is not always wrong.
So let's say you get lost in the woods and you're going to die of starvation unless you steal some food from a 7-Eleven.
Most people would agree that your theft is justified in that case.
Yeah, from.
The 7-Eleven in the middle of the woods where you 're starving with no human connection,
but magically there is a 7-Eleven.
Okay, okay, okay, fair.
Okay, well, maybe you're like in the woods and then you stumble upon a main road that has a 7-Eleven.
You realize it was nearby all along.
Or, okay, maybe it's a farmhouse.
There's like a nearby farmhouse and you can see a little light on.