The curse of Toumaï: an ancient skull, a disputed femur and a bitter feud over humanity’s origins

图马伊的诅咒:一颗古老的头骨,一段有争议的股骨,以及关于人类起源的激烈纷争

The Audio Long Read

2025-07-21

58 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

When fossilised remains were discovered in the Djurab desert in 2001, they were hailed as radically rewriting the history of our species. But not everyone was convinced – and the bitter argument that followed has consumed the lives of scholars ever since By Scott Sayare. Read by Bert Seymour. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/longreadpod
更多

单集文稿 ...

  • This is The Guardian.

  • On a late summer day in 2001, at the University of Poitiers in West Central France, the paleontologist Michel Brunet summoned his colleagues into a classroom.

  • to examine an unusual skull.

  • Brunet had just returned from Chad and brought with him an extremely ancient cranium.

  • It had been distorted by the eons spent beneath what is now the Jurab Desert.

  • A crust of black mineral deposits left it looking charred and slightly malevolent.

  • It sat on a table.

  • What is this thing?

  • Brunet wondered aloud.

  • He was behaving a bit theatrically, the professor Roberto Macchirelli recalled not long ago.

  • Brunet was a devoted teacher and scientist, then 61, but his competitive impulses were also known to be immoderate, and he seemed to take a ruthless pleasure in the jealousy of his peers.

  • Michel is a dominant male, Macchirelli told me.

  • He's a silverback gorilla.

  • Inspecting the skull, one could make out a mosaic of features, at once distinctly ape-like and distinctly human, a small brain case and prominent brow ridge, but also what seemed to be a rather unprotruding jaw, smallish canines, and a foramen magnum, the hole at the base of the skull through which the spinal cord connects to the brain, that suggested the possibility of an upright bearing, a two-legged gait.

  • Machiavelli told Brunet he did not know what to make of it.

  • Right answer, Brunet said.

  • The discovery was announced to the world the following year on the cover of Nature, the leading scientific journal, and in a televised ceremony in the Chadian capital, N'Djamena.

  • A new hominid is born, Brunet declared.

  • By virtue of his age, he is the ancestor of all Chadians.

  • but also the ancestor of the whole of humankind.