A critical look at MCP (News)

对MCP(新闻)的批判性审视

The Changelog: Software Development, Open Source

科技

2025-05-13

8 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

Rasmus Holm takes a critical look at MCP, Stefan Judis shares a new term he learned from Scott Hanselman, Raf beautifully describes the curse of knowing how, Void is an open source Cursor alternative & React Jam is back for its 6th online game jam.
更多

单集文稿 ...

  • What up nerds, I'm Jared and this is Changelog News for the week of Monday, May 12th, 2025.

  • Did you know that Claude's system prompt is over 24,000 tokens long?

  • That's some serious prompt engineering.

  • It's actually kind of fun to read,

  • especially if you imagine Claude standing in front of the mirror giving itself a pep talk before work.

  • Claude enjoys helping humans and sees this role as an intelligent and kind assistant.

  • Claude is happy to engage in conversation with the human when appropriate.

  • Claude often illustrates difficult concepts or ideas with relevant examples.

  • Claude does not provide information that could be used to make chemical or biological or nuclear weapons.

  • Now go get him, Claude, you brilliant golden retriever on acid.

  • Okay, let's get into the news.

  • A critical look at MCP.

  • Rasmus Holm is astonished by the apparent lack of mature engineering practices he sees as all the major players roll out model context protocol servers at a blistering pace.

  • All the major players spend billions of dollars on training and tuning their models,

  • only to turn around and,

  • from what I can tell, have an intern write the documentation,

  • providing subpar SDKs and very little in terms of implementation guidance.

  • This trend seems to have continued with MCP, resulting in some very strange design decisions,

  • poor documentation, and an even worse specification of the actual protocols.

  • His conclusion after diving deep into his own implementation of the protocol in Go,