The Problem With You

你的问题所在

Lexicon Valley from Booksmart Studios

社会与文化

2022-10-14

29 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

English used to have a more or less typical array of second person pronouns, with thou and thee for the singular — subject and object cases, respectively — and ye and you for the plural. So what happened? John explains. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit lexiconvalley.substack.com
更多

单集文稿 ...

  • From Booksmart Studios, this is Lexicon Valley, a podcast about language.

  • I'm John McWhorter, and you know, it's time for us to do you.

  • I'm referring to the pronoun you.

  • It's a funny, funny thing,

  • and I'd like to delve a little bit into what a funny thing it is and what it tells us about ourselves.

  • In other words, what you tells us about you, so to speak.

  • And what I refer to is this.

  • I, we.

  • He, she, it, they.

  • You there, you all there.

  • You and you.

  • That's the way a language is supposed to be, we think, because of course,

  • you know, English is the language of God, but it isn't.

  • It's one of 7,000 languages.

  • And for us, Singular you and plural you feels like Wheaties,

  • but no. Think about how odd that actually is.

  • What other language do you know where the word for you in the singular and the word for you in the plural,

  • so to speak, are the same thing?

  • Notice you have to unlearn that the minute you go to any other language.

  • So if you go to French, well, it's du in the singular and vous in the plural.