After Decades on the Court, I Want a Divided America to Know This

在法庭上呆了几十年,我希望分裂的美国知道这一点

The Opinions

新闻

2024-04-18

6 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

A former Supreme Court justice on how to disagree.
更多

单集文稿 ...

  • My name is Stephen Breyer.

  • I am now a retired Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court,

  • and I've written a book about the Court called "Reading the Constitution - Why I Chose Pragmatism,

  • Not Textualism."

  • There is a lot of disagreement among the people of this country on many issues,

  • and I wrote an essay to show or explain in the 28 years I was on the Court that the nine justices,

  • although they disagreed a lot on the law,

  • did not disagree about personal matters.

  • They were friends.

  • Here is my essay, "The Supreme Court I Served On Was Made Up of Friends."

  • Recently,

  • the Supreme Court Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Amy Coney Barrett spoke together publicly about how members of the Court speak civilly to one another while disagreeing,

  • sometimes vigorously, about the law.

  • Considerable disagreements on professional matters among the Supreme Court Justices,

  • important as they are, remain professional, not personal.

  • The members of the Court can and do get along well personally,

  • and that matters.

  • In my tenure, this meant that we could listen to one another,

  • which increased the chances of agreement or compromise.

  • It means that the Court will work better for the nation that it serves,