Tocqueville Road Trip: 2. Against all obstacles

托克维尔之旅:第二集——逆流而上

The Intelligence from The Economist

2026-06-13

44 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

Tocqueville saw America's faith in its own democracy as a vital force. But these days the majority of Americans think the country is headed in the wrong direction. Can a group of maximum security prisoners in Sing Sing offer a vision of how to get back on track? Guests and Hosts John Prideaux, The Economist's US EditorSean Pica, executive director of Hudson Link for Higher Education in Prison Jean Frantz, prisoner at Sing Sing Correctional Facility  Topics  Alexis de Tocqueville's views on voluntary associationsSing Sing prison education programmePrisoners' views on the American dream  To listen to the full series, subscribe to Economist Podcasts+
更多

单集文稿 ...

  • The Economist More than a league wide and covered with sails,

  • the Great River runs north into a range of high blue mountains and disappears.

  • Its banks are a scene of bustle and prosperity delightful to observe and overhead is an unmarriable sun whose rays,

  • filtering through the humid atmosphere of the region, bathe everything they touch in a soft, transparent light.

  • Alexis de Togfil wrote those words in a letter to his father.

  • He was perched in a tree at the top of a hill overlooking the Hudson Valley.

  • The French aristocrat was a few weeks into his trip around America.

  • After spending time with high society in New York, Togfil took a steamboat up the Hudson River.

  • Our one aim since we've come here has been to comprehend the land we are exploring.

  • We cannot accomplish that goal unless we disassemble society.

  • And I dare say no man, whatever his social rank, is incapable of teaching us something.

  • Tocqueville's next stop was what was then America's biggest prison, Sing Sing.

  • When he visited in 1831, it was just a few years old.

  • He had been commissioned to write a report on the American penal system for the French government.

  • That was the official reason for his trip, a great excuse to get funding for nine months studying a new democracy.

  • At Sing Sing, he wanted to see something called the New York system.

  • It was a novel approach that aimed to reform prisoners, not just punish them.

  • It combined work with solitary confinement.

  • The aim was to give prisoners time to reflect on their crimes, but also, through work, to give them purpose.

  • At the time it was considered progressive.