Peter Adamson on Avicenna's Flying Man

彼得·亚当森谈阿维森纳的飞人

Philosophy Bites

社会与文化

2012-11-26

13 分钟
PDF

单集简介 ...

Are we purely physical beings? Is the mind or soul immaterial? These questions have vexed philosophers for millenia. Avicenna, born in the 10th Century, believed he had a thought experiment that showed that we are not purely physical beings, the Flying Man thought experiment. Peter Adamson explains in this interview with Nigel Warburton for the Philosophy Bites podcast. Philosophy Bites is made in association with the Institute of Philosophy.
更多

单集文稿 ...

  • This is philosophy bytes with me, David.

  • Edmonds, and me, Nigel Warburton.

  • Philosophy Bytes is available at www.philosophybytes.com.

  • Philosophy Bytes is made in association with the Institute of Philosophy.

  • He may be the most significant philosopher you've never heard of.

  • The persian thinker Avicenna, born over a millennium ago, has already been the focus of one philosophy bite.

  • But according to one of his most articulate advocates, Peter Adamson, he's certainly worthy of another.

  • Here, Professor Adamson discusses one of Avicenna's most arresting thought experiments.

  • Peter Adamson, welcome to philosophy Bites.

  • Hi, it's good to be back.

  • The topic we're going to focus on this time is Avicenna's flying man.

  • So what is the flying man thought experiment?

  • Right.

  • Well, it's also called sometimes the floating man argument or even the falling man argument.

  • The idea is that God creates a fully grown, mature human being in thin air and also out of thin air.

  • So he's just started to exist.

  • He has no memory of previous existence, and in addition to having no memory, he crucially has no sensory input.

  • So he's blindfolded or veiled, and there's nothing for him to hear.

  • There's no wind, he's not even touching the ground because he's in mid air, and his limbs are splayed out so that he's not in contact with his own body, and there's no smell, and he's not eating anything.

  • All five senses are completely disabled, as it were, because there's nothing for him to experience.